Where Are We Heading Tonight?

30 09 2009

This is a question I see with growing frequency in guild chat or raid chat as the group fills up. This is because, as a guild, we are in a strange place with regard to progression. We’re not quite ready for ToC-25 hard modes, but doing Ulduar hard modes can seem a bit silly. They’re definitely harder than ToC-25 normal mode, but with (mostly) inferior loot.

This makes the term “progression” a bit loopy. There’s no doubt that Algalon is significantly more difficult than Northrend Beasts on normal mode, but Algalon’s loot is a few item levels lower. If you look back at previous expansions, raiding progression was a bit more linear. In pre-BC, you started off with a mix of Onyxia and Molten Core. When you could reliably kill Ragnaros, you’d probably move on to a mix of ZG (which was harder than MC) and Blackwing Lair. Then you’d start playing around with AQ20 and AQ40. Then, if you were awesome, you’d head into Naxxramas (when it was actually hard).

A mishmash of progression

A mishmash of progression

In BC there were significantly more raids but again a fairly linear progression. You started with a mix of Karazhan and Gruul’s Lair, moving up to Magtheridon and then upgrading to the next “tier” of gear when you were ready. In Wrath, you can get Ulduar level gear from heroics. You can get ToC-25 level gear from an instance that is easily pugged (Vault). Malygos, Sartharionx3 and Kel’Thuzad drop loot that is comparable (and in some cases superior, as with the Signet of Manifested Pain and Pennant Cloak) to Ulduar gear.

Onyxia muddies the water even more. Another puggable instance that drops ilvl 245 gear! It’s crazy! Is it better, though? Hard modes have certainly made progression a fuzzier line than before. While I do certainly enjoy attempting (and later succeeding at, hopefully) the Ulduar-25 hardmodes, it feels off to be doing them after completing the normal mode of ToC. Invariably, progression is measured by the kind of loot you can get from an instance. So Ulduar is behind ToC in these terms. The major change we have seen in the last few patches of WotLK is that difficulty no longer necessarily scales with ilvl.

I recall talking to my GM about the subject (or at least something closely related) and he lamented the lack of a middleground. Something between ToC hardmode and ToC normal (which is simply too easy and a bit boring) for guilds that fall between casual and hardcore. What could this be, though? Perhaps if hard modes could be calibrated multiple ways with different loot, as with Sartharion, there would be more for middle-of-the-road guilds to do. This is my major frustration with having “hard” and “normal” modes. Where’s the middleground?

The basis for creating it is there. Have Freya with two trees alive drop, say, ilvl 236 loot (between 226 and 239, which is the ilvl of Ulduar hard mode gear). This would require tweaking of certain hard modes, such as Mimiron, where you have everything built into the press of the button. For other fights, such as the previously mentioned Freya encounter and Hodir, calibrating loot drops to have normal, medium and hard drops wouldn’t be too much of a stretch. It would also follow Blizzard’s trend of giving its players options.

Be casual, be hardcore, be casualcore. Play as much as you want. Just hope that Blizzard notices you and gives you something appropriate to your skill level to do.




6 responses

1 10 2009

I was talking about this just yesterday — it seems to be a feeling in the air. Progression just doesn’t feel like progression anymore, and it forces casual players to compete with raiders on their own turf so to speak.

When I wanna be a casual player, I have a tendency to ignore gear because I’m just hanging out to socialize — when I’m raiding all the time, I pay a lot of attention to my ilevels and what I have to do to get it… and I just don’t appreciate being handed loot that doesn’t match the content.

1 10 2009

Also, I am seeing a trend where a higher iLevel doesn’t necessarily mean it is better. I recently tried mixing the Tier 9 2pc with Tier 8.5 2pc and see what the results were.

In the end of the experiment, I ended up using gear from 10/Uld normal to maximize and it still wasn’t as good as my full Tier 8.5.

If you get a chance, and the education, could you do a coverage of Rawr and how to effectively use it? I use it as a guideline for upgrades (but I still apply common sense) but the basic instructions from their site are a little too basic if you know what I mean….

1 10 2009

I’m really not a math or spreadsheet person, but if I get some time over the weekend I’ll try and take a look at Rawr. No promises.

Speaking of mixing ilvls, I find it sad that the plate boots from Trial of the Champion (5man) heroic are better than the ones from Vezax-25. 😦

2 10 2009

lul challenger, you still get to keep that title?

I ❤ rawr, though mostly using it for Hpally.

Anyway, ony '10' after 3s tomorrow, if ya know what I mean! I'll cover your repair bills if you don't QQ about it.

1 10 2009

The “medium modes” in Ulduar do give slightly better loot, or so I’ve read, but in the form of Runed Orbs, recipes and at least sometimes extra badges.

1 10 2009

That stuff isn’t so much “loot” in the typical sense of gear, but just little extra things that you can get from regular boss kills.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: